Best Friends Animal Society

Network Home CommunitiesOklahoma News The Cost of Kindness - Are You Really Ready To Start A Rescue?"
Oklahoma's place on the Best Friends Network More>
Prev17 of 17 stories Next
Print
Oklahoma

The Cost of Kindness - Are You Really Ready To Start A Rescue?"

April 24, 2008 : 3:41 PM
Animal rescue can be rewarding, but overwhelming, if you don’t plan for both the expected and the unexpected.

Lately within the state of Oklahoma, and probably many other locations, we have seen rescues struggle to operate effectively. Many of these rescues meant well when they began, but quickly became overwhelmed. Many are simply naïve. One recent rescuer commented that she assumed her new rescue website would bring in more donations, when in fact it only resulted in a staggering increase of cries for help to take a dog. Another rescuer indicated they were hoping their 501 c 3 would hurry up and get processed, because she was under the impression it would automatically result in many donations and free food from PetsMart.

Then, there is the perception of people who don’t want to surrender their animals to rescues, saying they “don’t like” the idea of rescues ‘making money’ off those animals with their adoption fees. Instead, they try to give them away on publications such as Free Cycle, and do not qualify adopters. They are not aware that adoption fees, often $35-$250, frequently don’t begin to cover the expense of neutering, vaccinating, de-worming, feeding, and providing flea and tick meds for even one month.

Animal rescue can be a very rewarding opportunity it you plan properly and can manage, but you can contribute to the problem if you end up needing to be rescued yourself and don’t plan for the unexpected.

Some financial facts:

Kim at OK SAVE A DOG recently adopted out a female cocker she had rescued six weeks earlier. The adoption fee was $100, and Kim anticipated she lost money on her even though she was already spayed. Kim is not complaining, indicating “this is what rescue is all about!” But, these are the types of issues that cause many rescues to cut corners in an attempt to remain open and afloat hoping things will change.

Kim continues some thoughts here:

Much of what people (rescues) do not think about are the "extra" things, not just the vet work.

For certain animals like Missy (the cocker) there was grooming (remember what a mess she was?).

Here is Missy after four baths and grooming!





Then, there are bowls, buckets, fences, pens, beds, blankets, sheets towels, crates, rakes, shovels, and dog houses. I have three buildings; one was $2200, one was $800, one was $1250. I needed two large dog houses at $400. All those funds have to be obtained. Most people think I get grants and discounts, but I can honestly say I get not one discount and have paid for everything I have just the same as an average person pays for it.

I figured out that it costs an average of $250 to get a dog ready for adoption. There are many dogs for which I receive only a $50 adoption fee, and some I can charge a larger adoption fee.. This helps to balance it out, but it takes planning. Some people criticized me for having an adoption fee of $200 for a little Yorkie, but that is what the market allows for and it helps pay for the other ones that do not move quickly.



Here is Lucy, the pregnant lab we rescued who gave birth to 10 puppies with canine herpesvirus, and who herself contracted ehrlichia; the cost of treating her and her pups was escalating, and I still lost six of those puppies despite all the efforts.

When I have a heartworm positive dog, the costs skyrocket. I spend about $200 a month on flea and tick medications alone. All dogs are wormed, on heartworm preventative, and given flea/tick medications monthly, so the bigger they are and the longer they stay here, the more costs they absorb. I have a heartworm positive dog like Trixie who has been here 4 months. I have mange pups that came and needed extra medications and help. Then, I have wonderful deserving dogs like Simon who is here simply because no one wants him.

It is not unusual for me to sit down and buy $300 worth of buckets or chews. My rescue and transport truck requires insurance, tires, gas, registration - that stuff is not considered. I have talked to rescues who think only about the food and vet bills. For me, the vet alone last year was $19,000. That does not count the shots that I do myself. Food in 2007 was $12,000.

Tina from Forever Friends Humane Society added some thoughts of her own:

I agree with all that Kim said. I have done the same thing as in spending for fencing, buildings, dog houses, etc. The vet bills are never ending. My bill this month is $850, last month it was $675 and the month before it was $500. There is always animals that get sick, there is always medications to buy, there is always altering to be done. Some things are not much, but it adds up after a while! I have to add new bedding every 2 weeks for the dog houses, which gets costly at $5 per bag! I do get many donations from Petco for dog food, but most of the time it is adult food; I usually have to buy the puppy food.

Someone asked me once why I go every weekend to do pet adoptions. Well, it is so I can pay the bills! I never have a free weekend, and it seems at times that I am completely on the go Friday-Saturday-Sunday. Rescue is very tiring and sometimes with my lupus I get by on my last bit of energy, but it has to be done. You just do what you’ve got to do! I know we all have spent so much out of our own pockets to help the animals. I try to send some when another group needs it, as I know for sure that every little bit helps.



Here is a picture of Cheryl and Betty one night descending on a failed rescue operation and trying to catch and round up cats in February of 2007.





The house was a complete mess. It was unsanitary, unhealthy, and cats were hiding in cabinets, in closets, and behind the furnace. Certainly, the rescue did not intend for things to end up this way, but the lack of planning and eventual abandonment (the owner went in to hiding due to fear of cruelty charges), placed a burden on rescues already overloaded.

Tina continues: Right now, one of our biggest expenses is gas. Cheryl drives all over the place every week and spends hundreds on gas. I drive to Fayetteville and Ft. Smith at least 10 times a month to do adoption events. I had a lady tell me one day at the adoption event: "$35.00 is a lot to ask for a mutt puppy, I will take one if you weren't asking so much." I told her this wasn't a garage sale, and then I informed her that they had their shots, worming, and frontline. She said, "Well, then I will give you what you have in the puppy then." So I took out a piece of paper and this is what I put and then handed it to her:

Puppy shots - $3 each (this pup has all 3)
Puppy worming - $2
Frontline - $2
Puppy food - $20
Puppy bath - $3
Puppy antibiotics - $15
Puppy bandana - $2
Gas to get to Petco - $40
Time I got to spend with puppy - Priceless!

She walked away. It doesn’t matter - I wouldn't have let her adopt after the first part of our conversation. Last month, I adopted out 124 puppies, so by doing the math you can see there is no way to ever come out ahead! Here is our 2007 cash recap:

Beginning Cash Balance: -2,598.61
Donations: 3,078.00 (included in deposits)
Deposits: 38,468.24
Interest Paid: 1,025.19
Vet & Medical : 13,404.38
Supplies (food, kennel, etc.): 9,319.61
Office Supplies: 7,089.98
Building Supplies: 269.48
Advertising: 147.10
Mileage (tolls, gas, etc): 7,135.98
Storage Unit: 420.00
Fee Reimbursement: 1,288.00
Fees Paid Other Groups: 2,130.00
Fees for Licensing: 775.00
Insurance: -0- (variable)
Meals: 953.12
Ending Cash Balance: -5,484.60

Kim concludes: “We need a ‘what happens to free dogs’ episode as much as we needed Oprah and the puppy mills story! Please tell people about the medical labs, the puppy mills, dogs being used for bait, and other bad things that happen.”

How You Can Help:

Support your local shelter or rescue such as OK SAVE A DOG or Forever Friends Humane Society. If you are not familiar with those two, there are probably local rescues in your area who would love to have your help! Post below and we’ll match you up with some good rescues in your area.

Attend a BF Sanctuary starter workshop.

Participate in the sanctuary forums on the Best Friends Network.

Review the Best Friends document How To Start A Sanctuary.

Written and posted by Marti Lombardi, Volunteer for the Oklahoma Community of the Best Friends Animal Society

Pictured is Oscar, a friendly Staffordshire Bull Terrier at FFHS who was skin and bones but gained 46 pounds and is now ready for his forever home.


Sign in to post a comment
Comments
  
May 24, 2008 at 11:16 PM
posted by: CJAnderson
Bravo! applause! Ovation!
Hard considerations that need to be said and why I support the Best Friends community building!

We so need to find ways to support each other and work together to get all our needs met! There MUST be the win=win in working to find HOW we are the same and can get the product - the pet into the new forever home to the public.

You are reinforced my determination to help to educate the public! I am so glad to be a part of this group and will work to try to continue to find ways my skills can support this very important work!
  
May 4, 2008 at 2:13 AM
posted by: moonvine
I wonder how much this varies by area as we do get lots of discounts and donations.
Although I can't say that 501(c)(3) status automatically qualifies you for many donations and free food from PetSmart (we have never gotten free food from PetSmart, though we have gotten free food from a local feed store)
Since we adopt out all our animals spayed and neutered - if someone wants to give us what we have put into them - it usually is more than the cost of the adoption donation - in fact I am happy we only lost $1 on our most recent kitty we adopted out. So we have to make up for it in other ways...
  
April 30, 2008 at 11:21 AM
posted by: Celeste
Thanks so much for making this important point, Marti!

Just one of the many reasons that I'm all about spay/neuter--it's so inexpensive and easy compared to rescue. :)

For more information, please see the Sheltering is Pointless...Until the Need is Reduced article in the Best Friends Resource Library.

In kindness,
Celeste Crimi
Network Member Support
Best Friends Animal Society
  
April 30, 2008 at 9:31 AM
posted by: rmlamasney25
Marti, Tina & Kim, thank you for all your hard work, heartache and worry that you do for these souls who have no one else to help and nowhere else to go. I'd been thinking of animal rescue onece I retire. Right now because of work and family the best I can do is support financially, join in email/phone campaigns, and occasional in person protest. This article was big in educating me as to the reality of what is involved. I think the important point I'm taking away is, there's plenty of great orgs. in my area I can become physically active with, under whose "umbrellas" I can do the work without having to start a whole new venture. Excellent article, thanks again.
  
April 30, 2008 at 1:29 AM
posted by: shelleyt
Thank you for this excellent and informative article - and for making us all a little more aware. Much appreciated.
  
April 29, 2008 at 11:21 PM
posted by: Lavanya
Thank you for writing such a great article Marti! The trend of overwhelmed rescues is nationwide. I hope that your article will help open up people's eyes - those in rescue as well as those who are looking to adopt an animal.
  
April 29, 2008 at 9:50 PM
posted by: yvette
Great great great article! Thank you for pointing out the expenses.....i am not an "official" rescue - I am just a woman trying to help animals all by myself and all the expense comes out of my pocket, my income, whatever is left over after mortgage, bills, and my (permanent) pets vet care.
I do ask for donations and gladly except them, and people know it's not tax deductible, and I appreciate any and all help; whether it's money or the offer to foster.

I foster cats in my home - so there is additional home expenses when a cat tears up my wood trim from scratching on the bathroom door all day, or scratches up the drywall, destroys throw rugs, breaks the screens on the windows, the list goes on....

Rescuing a rewarding, but it's one of those things where it's hard to see an end....and there is no way anyone involved in rescue is coming ahead in anyway expect to have a heart overflowing with love for the animals.
  
April 29, 2008 at 8:11 PM
posted by: kiticat
Yes, rescues generally run into many of the problems shelters do and bigger orgs can-- just faster and easier! Everyone starts out "thinking" their rescue will jump the hurdles and thrive bc its initiated out of strong compassion and passion, itself--believing everyone will want to help this noble cause as much as you!.

Then you turn to your vet who you think will share that same compassion but they dont or can't. And the fosters who you thought were in it to the end can no longer help due to various issues. And in your mind you believe that every animal YOU rescue will be adopted, only to find out people would love another animal but the 1-2 they already have is enough for them--and the gloomy list goes on and on. The well- intentioned efforts eventually turn into a pile of problems forming a trap where the animals become the real victims once again.

Being in rescue and starting from ground zero with no pre-plan or resources can rapidly lead you to a dead end--hopefully not literally. It can quickly turn into a "hoarding" situation or bring forth outcomes such as TR and alike due to the depressed state of affairs that can manifest ; a trap with no recourse and the potential to destroy everything in its hold.

Speaking from experience, my suggestion to people who are so determined to get involved --which is needed--to get involved under a bigger umbrella of rescue efforts. Expand efforts through a credible and well organized rescue to help increase the needed assistance, resources, and volunteer hands. By building extensions to a formed entity you will more effectively address the issues and efficiently handle the load leading to successful and happier tails.

Although noble and rewarding at times, Rescue can take more than it gives --so think twice or three times before initiating a cause as the very thing you wanted to help may easily end up hurting the very things you wanted to save.

Become resources for organized groups and add to the manpower--especially in today's economic climate. Even the organized groups will progressively have more hardship than normal with the increase of needy animals on the homefront. Become involved, not isolated.

A word from the wiser!
  
April 29, 2008 at 5:10 PM
posted by: Frans_Hoffman
Thanks for the article. I think most of us are painfully aware of the fact that when a rescue fails, it is the animals who suffer. Case in point: the Tiger Ranch in PA, which was a no-kill facility, where the animals were catnapped by the PSPCA, a kill-facility. More than 130 cats from TR have been killed so far, probably including cats that were saved from kill-shelters, that had been given all their shots, that were spayed/neutered etc... Sometimes, when we stumble, we give the other side an opportunity to hurt the animals we're trying to save.

There are so few places where animals can be placed safely. My wife and I at one stage considered starting a rescue and quickly realized that we would not be able to finance it in the long run. Instead, we decided to donate as much money as we can to existing rescues (and to volunteer with them).

I admire the work you are doing!
  
April 25, 2008 at 11:46 AM
posted by: kathy_g
Marti-
No one could have written this better.
T-great picture, and you're right. :)
Thank you to all who care enough to give their all.
  
April 25, 2008 at 11:13 AM
posted by: puppylady
Thank all of you who seem to understand! And Marti thank you for all that you do to educate people, in rescue and out of rescue. As we all know, it is one of those things, Once you start...You just can't stop! I have tried to cut back and then I see that pitiful little face looking up at me through bars and I just cannot leave it behind! So I guess as long as the Good Lord gives me strength to go on I am in it for the haul! The finance does become a burden but the reward of seeing one in a loving home with a family to call it's own is again....Priceless!!!

Tina - Forever Friends Humane Society
  
April 25, 2008 at 10:55 AM
posted by: frankie_paws
Fabulous article, Marti. Blessings to all who rescue for their never-ending dedication to all animals in need.
Tracy, your picture says it all.
  
April 24, 2008 at 11:06 PM
posted by: just_tracy
It is enough to make you wonder how (or why!) anyone would go into the rescue world...

Wait.

Oh yeah...



THIS is why...
  
April 24, 2008 at 10:00 PM
posted by: pattycatty
Marti,
This does seem fiscally daunting. But like starting a business for profit, a detailed business plan and some clear access to capitol would seem a necessity no matter how charitable the intention.

I think those posters who criticized Best Friends for seeking donations for the Vicktory Dogs, despite the hefty court award, should read your article. You can never stop seeking funds from every possible direction when you are existing as a nonprofit entity. Fundraising has to be a 24/7 effort.

Thanks for the research. It's an eye opener.
  
April 24, 2008 at 7:26 PM
posted by: MartiL
Jennifer - it is indeed a thought provoking set of statistics and information!

I failed to mention in the article that FFHS has had their own community for about a month!
http://www.network.bestfriends.org/ffhs/news
  
April 24, 2008 at 5:45 PM
posted by: jhayes
Wow great article. While it is easy to want to just jump in and rescue animals, people need to be made aware of the true costs and facts associated with saving animals. Now you hear more than ever about rescue organizations that get in over their heads and it's the animals who suffer. Your article should be required reading.

I just have to comment, $35 for a puppy expensive! Yikes, I can't believe that you are able to adopt them out so inexpensively. Kim and Tina, keep up the great work!
Welcome to the Best Friends Network!
Join the Best Friends Network today!
It’s the best place online to connect with other animal people, have fun, and help save lives in your community and all over the world. Learn More About the Best Friends Network or Join Now.
Member Log In  
Username or Email:  
Password:
 
 
   
Featured Member
BaileyGirl
I have had pets & loved animals all of my life....I started rescuing...

Join a Community
Florida
Florida's place on the Best Friends Network
Join a Campaign
Nye County Cat Rescue
Best Friends called in to assist more than 800 cats in distress in Pahrump, Nevada.

Truth about the Pet Trade

A coalition of kindness to animals caught in the pet trade.