Best Friends Animal Society

Network Home CommunitiesNew York News Port Authority Cat Extermination Campaign Stalls as Animal Groups Keep Up Pressure
New York's place on the Best Friends Network More>
Prev of 110 stories Next
Print
New York

Port Authority Cat Extermination Campaign Stalls as Animal Groups Keep Up Pressure

October 25, 2007 : 10:39 PM
"USA Today" Features Protest Effort

Read the follow up to the Feral Cat demonstration at USA Today by clicking here

UPDATE
by Bryan Kortis, Neighborhood Cats
headcat@neighborhoodcats.org
212-662-5761

(New York, Nov. 19, 2007) On Thursday, Nov. 15, a coalition of animal groups and concerned activists demonstrated for the second time in front of Port Authority of NY and NJ's headquarters in Manhattan. Despite the cold and rain, a large crowd gathered to loudly protest the Port Authority's ongoing efforts to exterminate all feral cats on the grounds of JFK Airport. Later the same day, Valerie Sicignano of In Defense of Animals and the NYC Feral Cat Initiative, and Bryan Kortis of Neighborhood Cats addressed the agency's Board of Commissioners, criticizing the eradication program and the lies and misrepresentations offered by the agency to justify the killing. They demanded (1) a permanent halt to the trapping, (2) a lifting of the feeding ban, and (3) implementation of a one-year pilot Trap-Neuter-Return program.

Meanwhile, the extermination effort appears to have stalled with no new cats having been surrendered to the local animal control shelter since November 7. All 24 victims of the trapping so far have been saved by local groups working with the NYC Feral Cat Initiative, a program of the Mayor's Alliance for NYC's Animals.

The protest effort and the as yet unsuccessful extermination program were featured today in a page 3 article in USA Today (See http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-11-18-cats_N.htm)

The article reports that Port Authority has "suspended" the trapping and is trying to work with animal groups to find an acceptable solution. However, the Port Authority has not stated it will permanently discontinue the effort and has not agreed to a Trap-Neuter-Return program. "The public needs to know nothing has been resolved," said Bryan Kortis, Neighborhood Cats. "The threat to fire any airport worker who feeds the cats remains in place, and the cruel attempt to trap and kill these cats could resume at any time. The community's outrage has slowed their campaign, but not yet stopped it once and for all. We're not letting up until this is a done deal."

WHAT YOU CAN DO NOW
*Write a Letter to the Editor of USA Today thanking them for the article and supporting Trap-Neuter-Return at JFK. You can write to "letters@usatoday.com" and include name, phone number, city and state for verification. Or else use the online form at: http://feedbackforms.usatoday.com/marketing/feedback/feedback-online.aspx?type=18

Letter from Michael Mountain to USA Today. Read what the President of Best Friends Animal Society has to say:
Whenever our fellow animals seem to be getting in the way of humans, the first solution is almost always to kill them. And the onus is placed on animal protection groups to come up with an alternative that will be considered acceptable to the killing lobby.

Twenty years ago, 17 million homeless pets were being destroyed each year in shelters all across the nation. This was justified as being a "necessary evil", as if there were no options. But today, fewer than 4 million are killed each year, thanks to the growth of the no-kill movement and the new emphasis on spay/neuter for cats and dogs. It will be sad if the JFK cats are among the 4 million put down this year, because killing is never the answer. It’s morally bankrupt and it doesn’t work; it simply opens the door to more killing.

The cats at JFK pose no danger to human health or safety. Nor did they get there by choice. They are our responsibility, and there are people who are ready, willing and able to look after them. So we need to invert our priorities: Destroying them should not be a first option; it should not even be a final option. Only when we take it off the table altogether -- whether in relation to a few cats at an airport, to homeless animals everywhere, or indeed to other living creatures for whatever reason -- will we humans be able to live at peace with ourselves and each other.


*Post comments in the USA Today blog using the form at the bottom of the page where the article is posted online: http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-11-18-cats_N.htm

*Keep sending those phone calls and emails! Take a few minutes each day and make a phone call or send an email to one or more of the names listed on the home page of Neighborhood Cats (www.neighborhoodcats.org ). What matters now as much as what you say is that you're still saying it - remember, they thought we'd all go away after a day or two. It's been three weeks now and the publicity and protest is only growing - they are being forced to deal with this because YOU are making them. So don't feel like what you're doing is repetitious and unimportant - it's vital and the more they hear from you, the better our chances to save these cats. Try to leave the words "JFK" and "cats" out of the emails so they can't be automatically blocked.

We're making progress, but not home yet!! THANK YOU!!!

Photo courtesy of http://www.neighborhoodcats.org


Sign in to post a comment
Comments
  
November 21, 2007 at 11:30 AM
posted by: shellyk
this is a great example of how powerful the net work can be..
  
November 19, 2007 at 2:23 PM
posted by: eileenwj
Thank you Brian and Neighborhood Cats. We are very grateful to your good work.
Eileen Weintraub
Seattle, WA
  
November 8, 2007 at 7:28 PM
posted by: evgraf13
What planet are these bureaucrats from? ANY cat, social or feral, would be scared to death of anything as noisy as a moving aircraft and wouldn't go anywhere near it.
  
November 6, 2007 at 12:36 PM
posted by: njanmlrsq3
Cuda...

No one will blast you for those words. That is your opinion, 1st Amendment right. However, this is what Best Friends Network members do. Network members take action against organizations and even agencies if they feel there is a threat to animals. This is not Staff members spending money on every little case. These are volunteers on thier own time handling issues like JFK.

In regards to Pets Alive, I will say that the situation at that Sanctaury was in dire straits and Best Friends needed to act. I know this as I was on site 2 weeks after Best Friends arrived.

This news article is about a demonstration and not about what Best Friends does or doesn't do.
How about you try the anything goes forum, here is the link http://network.bestfriends.org/MessageBoards/Forum.aspx?f=735

To everyone else... I am gonna see if I can attend this demonstration. I am not a big fan of what the Port Authority is doing in regards to the Feral Cats.

George DeGiovanni
NJ Community Writer
Best Friends Network
  
November 3, 2007 at 5:34 PM
posted by: cuda
I am sure someone will blast me for this, but BF cannot save every single bad situation that comes up. I am sure they wish they could, but things like Pets Alive and Pahrump. NV take a toll on funds. Plus, they have the sanctuary that is a priority thru all this.
Second, if one of you is really good in diplomacy this is a website for the "Cats on Parliament Hill". Maybe our politicians could learn something from the Canadians. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Parliamentary_Cats
http://www.parliamenthill.gc.ca/text/explorecatsanctuary_e.html
These cats are in Ottawa, Ontario. This story is really wonderful. If local vets would help in the spay/neuter of these cats maybe they could keep their home. To me all the Port is doing is giving people the perfect dumping ground. Get someone else to kill the cat for them.
Funny part is that the cats attract birds. I have yet to see a bird fly next to a cat
  
November 3, 2007 at 11:55 AM
posted by: ratmom
Ignorance must be bliss.

Once they exterminate all the cats, they apparently don't understand that other cats will move in. Therefore, EXTERMINATION DOES NOT WORK.

What I don't understand is why do these requirements to clear the place of cats come up out of the blue? All of a sudden, cats are causing planes to crash? I guess that's part of the blissful ignorance.

New Yorkers rule! Keep up the good fight.
  
November 2, 2007 at 4:40 PM
posted by: JoannaHarkin
There are organizations trying to help with this by forcing the airport to allow the cats to remain where at the airport, which of course is ideal. It doesn't seem to be working out. Below (very long -- my apologies) is a post to someone at Purrfect Fence which makes cat fencing and to some rescuers in upstate NY asking for an acre of land on which to hold cats pending further relocations. It would be wonderful if BF through PetsAlive could possibly spare an acre or two to temporarily relocate the cats pending rehoming in small groups or pairs to adopters able to accept feral cats and give them proper relocation protocols in proper faculties or locations. Clearly another option would be to enclose with cat fencing some of the airport's 5,000(!) acre campus. How about one acre for the cats with a building or shed so the cats could be fed inside where the seagulls and birds could not access the food??

SENT TO MANAGER at PurrfectFence, which makes cat fencing: This is Joanna Harkin in Wash. DC and I just got off the phone with you about the cats being trapped and probably euthanized by animal control in NYC. Here is a post I wrote last night on the feral cat egroup, prefaced by one forwarding it to people who helped when the Catskill Game Farm was closing last year. If someone would help with some land, maybe Purrfect Fence would see it's way clear to help enclose an area on someone's property in order to confine cats, pending relocation in pairs or in small groups. Here is a link about the cats being trapped but if you Google JFK cats you will find many many more ... http://www.nypost.com/seven/10302007/news/regionalnews/no_paws_in_jfk_cat_hunt.htm

POSTED ON ELIST of those who helped Catskill Game Farm animals: Below is a message I posted on a NYC feral cat egroup. If anyone here can loan use of an acre or two, I'll see if we can raise about $5,000 in order to set up a temporary harbor for these cats, and maintain them for say 6-8 months in the expectation that by then they could be transferred out properly to barn homes in pairs or small groups.

Two follow-up posts state that both Best Friends and Pets Alive were contacted and are unable to assist. Probably the question posted was, "Can you take some cats?" and not "Might you let us have some space for them for 6-8 months in order to maintain and then relocate between 100 and 200 feral cats?"

So -- for clarity -- I am asking members of this list to consider the following: might you be in a position to assist these cats -- literally save their lives -- with some acreage (ideally with a barn or shed) that could be used to contain and maintain these cats for a period of 6-8 months?

I envision setting up a cat fencing enclosure fundraised from those concerned about these cats (perhaps one of the large organizations would help out with seed money) for fencing, food, shelters and caretaking for about 150 cats for 6-8 months?

Permission to forward to persons potentially able to help granted, but please do not post extensively or on Craigs List. Experts say this cannot be done, so I'm just putting out feelers to see what might be possible. Then I have to dig up funds, because I know members of this egroup have gone down that garden path before: leading with the heart and being left holding the bag, or maybe a hungry rhino. Please contact me directly at joannaharkin @ gmail.com (close up the spaces).

POSTED BY ME AT 3 AM 11/2/07 on a NYC feral cat egroup: Ideally the cats will be allowed to stay in their home territory to which they are accustomed and to which their brains are hard-wired, but it's not looking good .....

Here is a possible fall-back plan of action: (1) trap and vet the felines (or retrieve them from animal control and vet them); (2) confine them using cat fencing to some property (perhaps a section at PetsAlive); (3) work on properly re-relocating them if something cannot be worked out to financially support the cats indefinitely at the stop-gap location. If New Yorkers want these cats to live, they can donate to support them. Has anyone reached out to Best Friends,
currently managing Pets Alive? (http://bestfriends.org <http://bestfriends.org/&gt; and http://petsalive.org <http://petsalive.org/&gt; )

And, yes, I know relocations are challenging and problematic, most of all for the cats, but I've been doing them for years and they are highly doable. Mostly it's a matter of finding places to put cats which takes time, but with time suitable adopters would accept pairs or small groups of vetted feral cats and adhere to proven feral-cat relocation protocols.

I assisted with the Catskill Game Farm auction and the listserv from that operation (exotic and other animals were bought at auction to preempt them from winding up in canned hunts) is still functioning. Maybe I should reach out to members of that list for a possible place to put 200 cats short-term (or longer-term if money can be raised to maintain them indefinitely without imposing on someone already sanctuarying larger animals). Pets Alive appeals to me because it is better set up to fundraise on-gong donations to support the cats after things cool down. We saw that happen with the Catskill Game Farm: drama drama drama and then the fanfare ended, and some people were left with pretty large animals to house and feed.

My vision requires on-going maintenance probably because what would be nice for the cats might be to stay together in a spacious confinement area of perhaps an acre or two. It's highly doable. I almost bought a farm with three acres enclosed for raising petting deer. I've seen such a set up and it can be done for these cats. Over last summer 100+ mostly sociable cats needed to be relocated and a rescue colleague accommodated them in a set-up such as I'm envisioning here: a modest structure and a few feral cat houses in a cat-fenced area of an eighth of an acre. If 100 cats can manage nicely with a heated garage-type building with a lot of deep and high shelves, then 200 cats can temporarily be contained comfortable in a half acre enclosure, or less if the cats will be relocated from there.

Just last month I relocated the last six of 14 feral cats from a 60-cat situation, which cats were trapped and maintained in a horse barn since shortly before September 11 when the ax fell for 36 tame cats at the trailer park location who were PTS by animal control. Another rescue colleague (an estate lawyer with a trust to maintain the cats after his death) was able to accept them, following tried and true feral cat relocation protocols, as also employed by Joan Scroggs of Long Island who transported some cats to his sanctuary in 1999 when this article appeared, in which I learned about Mylar: www.petfinder.com/journal/index.cgi?article=472

Relocations are a lot of work and by no means ideal, but if it comes to a cat dying . . . - Joanna Harkin, Wash DC jharkinhome @ gmail.com
  
November 2, 2007 at 3:18 AM
posted by: QMD333
Latest poll results:

What should happen to the feral cats at JFK Airport?

Results since OCTOBER 29TH, 2007

Euthanize them   8.0%

 Neuter and re-release them   90.0%

 Leave them alone   2.0%
  
October 31, 2007 at 3:41 PM
posted by: Spax
I also called the Inspector General's office (Wan Etten) and I'm shocked to say that the receptionist was laughing on the phone and saying "no one is killing cats, haha!". She did apologize later and gave me the number of Susan Baer's office (General Manager of JFK), which is 718-244-3501.
Please call, her receptionist is actually very nice and told me they got a lot of angry phonecalls. Good.
Andrea
  
October 31, 2007 at 3:25 PM
posted by: Spax
I just called Coscia's office again and insisted on speaking to a live person and not some automated bs line. They basically refuse to get calls so it's important to keep them flooded even if it's just the receptionist. I did get another person on the line but she also said they were instructed by the Port Authority to give the automated number and that she could take my name and # but of course no one is going to call back. Please keep calling though, we are the only voice these cats have!
Andrea
  
October 31, 2007 at 3:06 PM
posted by: Spax
I just called some numbers, Coscia's office gives you a different phone# to call which is just a faxline, the Port Authority connects you to an automated line. Everybody gives you the runaround, this is bs. They must have gotten tons of outraged calls by now!
Those poor cats, this is truly outrageous. Please keep the pressure up!
  
October 31, 2007 at 2:06 PM
posted by: atuttle32
I just took the poll, and I'm happy to say that 82% of the people are saying TNR.

This whole thing makes me sick. Humans as a species have gotten these poor cats into this mess. It is our job to get them out of it - but by helping not killing.

My prayers are with all the cats and kittens facing death, and with all the humans fighting for their right to live.
  
October 30, 2007 at 2:24 PM
posted by: sherylcatmom
Click here to take a poll asking "What should happen to the feral cats at JFK Airport?"
  
October 28, 2007 at 3:15 PM
posted by: DonArnold
There are many of us out here willing and able to go and trap and remove these animals to a safe place, but instead like always our goverment makes the wrong decission. And to think we elect them.
  
October 26, 2007 at 6:55 PM
posted by: QMD333
THIS IS AN OUTRAGE!!!!!

Never mind Osama Bin Laden.

Never mind the fact that fake bombs have made it onto planes, put there by media members measuring airline security.

Never mind the fact that the airlines let 18 terrorists on planes in ONE DAY.

Never mind the airlines letting a terrorist with a SHOE BOMB on a plane.

Lets forget about the news story a couple of years ago about the drunken pilots falling asleep in the cockpit, putting the plane on "cruise control".

No...lets worry about (Sarcasm Alert) the biggest threat facing the planes.....the most dangerous living beings of them all.....they strike fear in us all....they will blow the planes out of the sky.....they are.....feral cats?

This is one of the most ridiculous, ignorant things that any human has ever conceived in their noggin.

If ignorance is bliss, JFK airport is Shangri La.

From the second The Wright Brothers took flight, there has NEVER, EVER been an event where feral cats have brought down a plane.

Furthermore, if JFK airport had a clue, they would readily understand that 99% of feral cats will fail the "obedience-behavorial" test that animals get when first arriving at a shelter. Thus, JFK airport is sentencing innocent souls to death, FOR NO REASON.

18 HUMANS were responsible for the events of September 11. Not one of them was a cat.
As far as I know, there werent any cats holding box cutters, threatening pilots.

HUMANS are threats to airline safety, NOT CATS!

Wonders never cease.

PLEASE take action to help those cats!! Send the emails, make the phone calls, fax the letters!

We cannot allow this nonsensical killing to happen.

We can stop it.

WHAT YOU CAN DO
Call, fax and email Port Authority officials and protest the extermination effort. Urge them to meet with NYC Feral Cat Initiative representatives and come up with an intelligent plan to TNR and manage the JFK cats.
The NYC Feral Cat Initiative is a program of the Mayor's Alliance for NYC's Animals.

WHO TO CONTACT
Susan Baer, General Manager, JFK Airport
sbaer@panynj.gov
718-244-3501

Laura Francoeur, Aeronautical Services,
Airport Operations Division
Phone: 718-244-3773
Fax: 718-244-3777
lfrancoe@panynj.gov:

Public Affairs (Port Authority)
212 435-7777

LATEST UPDATE FROM NEIGHBORHOOD CATS:
They're telling callers that none of the 50 to 75 feral cats slated for trapping this weekend will be killed but will all be adopted into homes - yeah, right! Please call or write again and tell them you don't buy it - boy, they think we're real dumb. Cats down jets and ferals are all quickly adoptable.
Press links are below, plus story will be on local radio and TV. Keep the heat on!

NY POST
http://www.nypost.com/seven/10262007/news/regionalnews/fur_flies_at_jfk.htm
For Letter to the Editor (Include contact info.) : letters@nypost.com

NEWSDAY
http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wire/newyork/ny-bc-ny--airportcats1026oct26,0,336024.story
For Letter to the Editor: letters@newsday.com

STATEN ISLAND ADVANCE (AP article)
http://www.silive.com/newsflash/metro/index.ssf?/base/news-29/119338855129960.xml&storylist=simetro
To Submit a Letter to the Editor, Go To:
http://www.silive.com/contactus/

GOTHAMIST
http://gothamist.com/2007/10/26/claiming_danger.php

For more on the Mayor's Alliance for NYC's Animals: http://www.animalalliancenyc.org

For more on Neighborhood Cats: http://www.neighborhoodcats.org
Welcome to the Best Friends Network!
Join the Best Friends Network today!
It’s the best place online to connect with other animal people, have fun, and help save lives in your community and all over the world. Learn More About the Best Friends Network or Join Now.
Member Log In  
Username or Email:  
Password:
 
 
   
Featured Member
georgina9217
I'm a musician and animal lover. I made my first trip to Best Friends...

Join a Community
Arizona
Arizona's place on the Best Friends Network
Join a Campaign
First Home Forever Home
A place to learn, commit, and act on behalf of pets and their need for a loving, forever home.

Truth about the Pet Trade

A coalition of kindness to animals caught in the pet trade.