Good going, Shelly and Mayor Trively!
This is such good news. And you go little, Sidney, you're in good hands now.
Many thanks to TNRdoesn'twork; The website you posted is downright laughable. The obvious mistakes and easily proven inaccurate statements on the website are too numberous to count like the first one mentioned (was this supposed to be the strongest of your points?) saying feral cats must be good bird hunters since they can catch rodents pretty well. Any person with an ounce of intelligence can see how difficult it is for a cat to catch a bird compared to it running down a mouse or rat on the ground. I've seen my cats catch many mice but can't catch a bird to save their life. I am one of many thousands, maybe millions, of people who have seen first hand TNR reducing colony sizes as well as eliminating or dramatically reducing public complaints about the cats which trap and kill may only do temporarily at best. Trap and removal will just allow new unaltered cats to move in and they will bring all the problems of unneutered cats with them. When I volunteered at my shelter we would see the same people bringing in trapped cats for euthanasia. If trap and kill really had any effect these same people wouldn't have kept coming back with more cats. You also can't argue the fact that TNR is less costly to the taxpayers. And you can't argue that the way we got in this mess in the first place is the disposable attitude people have had about animals in the past. So using the barbaric trap and kill method in communities will just further this disposable mentality and won't offer any longterm solutions to problems related to either feral or owned cats. I see the only people believing in your cracked propaganda are bird lovers who are more than happy to kill cats even though it would make little difference at all in the bird population and also people who don't have any experience using TNR and believe just about anything they read on the internet.
http://www.tnrrealitycheck.com/
Posted
May 28, 2008, 12:38PM
by
Joy
Shelly sent me this photo and I just had to share. It's so precious! Shelly's dog Rocky just loves Sidney.
Sidney's getting so big! Awesome photo; thanks for sharing.
Posted
May 16, 2008, 3:0PM
by
Fletch
Keep us informed and hang in there Sidney
rescuerCalifornia - so glad you are easily amused, but I don't see you easily disproving anything on that website. The stated goal of TNR has little to do with reducing nuisance complaints and much to do with eliminating colonies or significantly reducing them - neither of which happens. Trap and remove does work when the food source is removed. TNR is a perpetual cycle. The difference is, in TNR, those cats that evade capture are fed and better able to breed and to hunt. What colonies have you elimated through TNR? TNR contributes to that disposable attitude because cats are re-abandoned outdoors. We cannot successfully convince people to be responsible pet owners, to spay and neuter their pets and keep them under control if we say that some cats can and should live and die outside in cat colonies.
Apparently, you are quite unfamiliar with the many organizations that do not endorse TNR. When you have time to do some homework and actually look into the science, then we can talk. Until then, I am laughing, too.
hey girls!!!GREAT JOB!!!She is soooocute!!!What color is she???And how is she doing now???mytwocats
mytwocats - Sidney is being followed in the Guardian Angel program.
Click here for her latest update.
Posted
May 15, 2008, 10:5PM
by
mimi
That's pretty perspecacious peepers Shelly and Anna have. To have spotted such a tiny, road-colored kitty...well, someone apparently wanted this kitty to have a little help. Well done!