Posted
July 26, 2007, 10:14AM
by
cattees
The words "Michael Vick" and "future" are oxymorons.
Posted
July 26, 2007, 8:40PM
by
bogiedew
Dont watch Nancy Grace if you want to be sick. Alls she shows is footage of dogs fighting.
I don't want to divert too far from this thread, but Tammy Grimes of DDB will be at the courthouse in Virginia today.
She also has four tickets to an NFL game she doesn't know what to do with and is solicting ideas on the DDB web site. She was going to auction them off but in light of recent events, has decided not to do so. If you have any ideas on how these tickets can be put to good use (polite ideas of course; some of mine aren't particularly nice), please let Tammy know.
Posted
July 27, 2007, 12:52PM
by
ruthy92
tippydog, there have been many many many terrible failures with "rehabilitating" fighting dogs, and primarily children and other pets have paid the price.
EVERY time that happens, the reputation of pit bulls goes down the drain.
The pit sanctuaries are overloaded. There are hoarders that will continue to take them, but that is horrific. But the pit resues and shelters are stretched to the limit!
Some of these dogs simply cannot get placed.
Not to mention, does it make sense to be housing unplaceable dogs for an eternity when lovely, problem-free pits are getting PTS in the shelters?
(and yes, quite a few high-profile pit "advocacy" groups either don't address the fighting at all and pretend it doesn't exist, or try to "explain away" scarring and fighting equipment. It's a disgrace, and one must wonder who their lobby really is)
I suspect the only way these dogs will be saved is if they're taken by a sanctuary where they would never be adopted out to a family. Other than BF, I have no idea where that would be...
I keep throwing out the idea of Southern Friends, a BF facility located in the rural south (like Alabama) but perhaps those found guilty in the Vick case could at least finance Pit City at the Kanab sanctuary. I know it wouldn't help these specific dogs but perhaps in the future when dogs arer "confiscated," they would have a special place to live in Kanab....
NFL Commissioner Goodell has already acknowledged publicly that the organization has no idea how widespread involvement in dog fighting is in the league.
This isn't just about a singular individual named Michael Vick. It's about a culture of violence and a culture of public figures who believe themselves to be above the law. And I would not be surprised to find that this particular dog ring extends beyond Virgnia; I'm told there's a possible connection to my home state of Alabama and that dogs may have been transported to Vick's property to fight.
A large Rally/Vigil is being held in Richmond tomorrow at 3:00 to coincide with Vick's court appearance. Sponsored by Virginia Voters for Animal Welfare and Dogs Deserve Better:
UPDATE: Dog Fighting Rally/Vigil In Richmond on Thursday, 7/26
Posted
July 26, 2007, 10:9AM
by
kathy_g
Today; as I go about the things I need to do, I am dressed in black in remembrance of all the unknown number of dogs who have suffered and died at the hands of this cruel activity. I will be at the courthouse in Spirit.
ruthy92,
fighting dogs have been successfully rehabilitated and placed in other situations. i am not suggesting that these dogs be placed with just anyone, nor placed in cages the rest of their lives. i am suggesting "appropriate" placement with highly qualified rescues and/or sanctuaries that are committed to doing what is right for these dogs. i also believe that many pitbull rescue groups are doing all they can to stop the breeding and the fighting and are advocating for this breed, but it is a huge task that is going to require a lot of collective effort. putting these dogs down is not the answer. and i think it would go along way for advocacy of the breed if it can be shown that these dogs are "salvagable" for lack of a better term. i think they deserve no less than our full effort to do what is right for each of these dogs, realizing that what may be right for one may not be right for the other.
Posted
July 26, 2007, 3:15PM
by
michelle
Also, CNN is currently at 2 pm CST reporting and showing footage "of hundreds.. perhaps thousands" (their quote)of demonstrators lining up against Vick outside courthouse for 2:30 pm hearing EST.
At 7pm tonight on Paula Zahn they will focus on the "Subculture of Dogfighting." Cable television news programs wil be all over this case/subject tonight. Court date just set for November 26.
Posted
July 26, 2007, 3:47PM
by
aml
WHERE did the adorable picture for this story come from? Does anyone know?
(Yes, I have signed the petition and forwarded and forwarded it on... I just think the picture is over the top gorgeous)
Thanks!
Rawlings dumped Vick yesterday:
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2007/football/nfl/07/31/bc.fbn.vick.rawlings.ap/index.htmlGood for them. I opined from the start that it was unlikely that Vick would face jail time and I hoped this would affect him financially. It is and it will.
He'll still have millions if he wants to fade off into the sunset or go buy some island to live on (fine with me) but I do hope he will not longer be a public figure and this his celebrity status will have served a purpose:
To educate people across our country about the horrors of this so called "sport" as a way of ending it once and for all.
Animal Fighting:
See the animal fighting laws in the state in which you live...
http://network.bestfriends.org/tennessee/news/8784.html
Get Political For Animals:
A Step-by-Step manual for how to win strong laws for animals in your area
http://network.bestfriends.org/utah/news/17093.html
Posted
July 26, 2007, 11:42AM
by
ruthy92
tippydog, some of the dogs that come out of dog fighting are NOT placeable.
It would be terribly unfair to other people and other pets, as well as the fighting dogs themselves, to place them.
They are terribly aggressive, and no amount of "training" can stop this in some of them.
This is something I know of first-hand.
It is NOT an acceptable alternative to keep them in cages for the rest of their lives.
And you have the dog fighters to blame for this.
If you focused your efforts on stopping the fighting and the breeding, then dogs would not end up in this situation.
That is where the the pit bull advocacy community has failed these dogs terribly. There has been little done about stopping the fighting and breeding.
Posted
July 27, 2007, 6:35PM
by
kendra
I agree with you, tippydog90. I think that there are so many factors that come together to determine behavior, that it is unfair to assume that these dogs are all aggressive and dangerous and will always be so. I think that it's only fair that these dogs be evaluated by a professional with experience working with and rehabilitating the breed. Hopefully, since the ASPCA is so involved with this case, their animal behaviorists will get a chance to give each dog a temperament test before euthanasia is determined.
It's only fair to give the dogs a chance. Plus, I think it undermines the severity of animal cruelty if the court decides to put down all of the animals involved anyway. It's like saying "We're going to punish you for hurting them, but then we're going to kill them because you hurt them." It doesn't make any sense to me...
I would like to encourage everyone to read the blog link posted below regarding restitution and the future of these dogs. I strongly believe that every effort should be made to place these dogs with highly qualified rescues and/or sanctuaries, or provide them with a place of their own. To euthanize these dogs would only compound the tragedy. Last week I also started a petition to the HSUS and local animal control agencies that are caring for these animals, asking them to make all efforts to place them. Right now, they are facing euthanasia after the trial. But I believe additional efforts should take place to save these dogs beyond this petition, but it is a start.
www.thepetitionsite.com/petition/219515592
One of Vick's co-defendants just pled out:
http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/law/07/30/vick.dogfighting/index.htmlThis bodes well for the prosecution. This man pled guilty, will get a reduced sentence and will most likely become the prosecution's key witness against the other defendants. It appears that Vick financed almost the entire......I'm not sure what to call it. I was gonna call it an "operation" but even that is too civilized a word.
Posted
July 25, 2007, 6:21PM
by
bullydog
Excellent point, southerndogmom. Thank you.
I think the public, in general, is getting very sickened by the favoritism showered upon these celebs. It's a very tiring message of rewarding people for their constant screw-ups -- those things which would get us "mere mortals" locked up for years. We get the justice we can afford, eh? It's a sad world.
"This isn't just about a singular individual named Michael Vick. It's about a culture of violence and a culture of public figures who believe themselves to be above the law. "
Posted
July 27, 2007, 12:58PM
by
ruthy92
kathy q, it is local government who makes the decision about euthanasia
Because they are the ones who will be held legally responsible (sued) should something happen
And there's a lot of litigation going on!
Posted
July 25, 2007, 11:55PM
by
pitbull
Check out the blog at
http://network.bestfriends.org/Blogs/PostDetail.aspx?bp=4838 for some interesting ideas on restitution. If this idea could be sold, the 54 seized dogs could have a chance at life....
thanks pitbull and phhaddock for those links.
And I too am glad BF posts the photos of the kind of dogs being brutalized. It highlights the beauty, nobility and inherent goodness that evil people try to pervert and destroy.
Posted
July 26, 2007, 9:37PM
by
kathy_g
Sadly, from what I've read, the HSUS has a policy which most shelters adhere to, stating that ANY fighting dog is NOT to be adopted out-not even puppies.
About a year or so ago here in Florida, there was a rather large dogfighting bust-it was heartbreaking the sheer number of dogs(and young puppies) that HAD to be PTS according to HSUS guidelines...no matter how sweet they were to humans-they could not leave the shelter alive.
Sad sad sad.
Out of all the animal abuse I've seen in my life-dogfighting is probably the one I hate the most.
ruthy92
i have never suggested adopting these dogs out, nor have i suggested that every single one of them should be placed. what i am saying is they deserve a chance to be evaluated. some of these dogs are likely pups that have never been fought. i have spoken to people that have worked with this dogs before and know that they can have a positive outcome, depending on the circumstances. i also worked with many, many of these dogs in the aftermath of katrina and was never once faced with even the slightest amount of aggression by any of these dogs (yes, many, many fighting dogs, you could tell by their battle scarred bodies). i also think there are possibly opportunities to use these dogs to advocate for the breed and i have ideas on how that might come about. and i think in turn, that will help the plight of the ones in shelters. the point is to take this tragedy and "try" to have a positive outcome, both for the individual dogs, and the breed. maybe if a conviction takes place, the proceeds from the sale of the property, which would be forfeited by the defendents, could be used to provide for some of these dogs as well as be used to help end this horrific practice. i think this tradegy just may provide an opportunity to help this breed, and help these poor dogs involved. it is just going to take a colloborative effort and people who are willing to try.
Up to date coverage of today's court hearing can be found at:
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/13760544/detail.htmlThere's protestors staged outside the courthouse both for and against Vick!
This is a very well written opinion piece which encourages people to look at Vick's behavior in context with other individuals and to not cast Vick in the role of a victim.
I like this quote: "The presumption of innocence does not extend to the world of print ads and TV spots. It stops at the courtroom steps, and if he didn’t know it before, Vick surely knows that now."
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20082273/
I'm very glad that Mr. Blank made the statement, "The notion that anyone could participate in dogfighiting is incomprehensible to me" in a public forum. This is what we're fighting for--people everywhere to realize that this is going on, that it's really bad, and that the people participating should be punished for the pain and suffering they are inflicting upon these poor creatures. This is very encouraging indeed, and I hope that if Vick is convicted, the NFL and other pro sports leagues will do what our petition asks, and make an official policy reagrding this atrocious activity.
(By the way, I LOVE the picture at the top of this article!)