Posted
April 29, 2007, 8:1PM
by
Sentient
I believe this is a scam by Fort Dodge (via a vet working under their thumb through a big-time advertising company that has questionable ethical practices).
I have submitted it to snopes.com so they can research it further, as they have better researchers than myself on their staff. I can find no studies or evidence online to back up these statements of a wide-spread new Calici outbreak requiring immediate vaccination with the new vaccine. All the "many" outbreaks I've seen posted are the word of mouth statements by one Dr. Norsworthy - a vet with current articles online that state blatantly FALSE facts with regards to current vaccination options and protocols. The only reference to calici outbreaks that matches the descriptions are on these webpages, which are several YEARS past now (the one outbreak I've seen documented by trusted sources happened in a very confined area in CA in 2002):
http://www.sheltermedicine.com/portal/is_vs_fcv.shtmlhttp://www.sheltermedicine.com/portal/journals.php http://www.goodnewsforpets.com/Articles.asp?ID=695 http://www.dvmvac.org/swiftaction.asp http://www.patentdebate.com/PATAPP/20040259225 (vaccine seems to have been at least partly patented in 2004 by UC Davis researchers)
I first heard of this in an email circulating, stating that an article was posted in the Claremont Sun newspaper by a Dr. Meakin, in Ohio. His emergency service told me over the phone that he does occasionally post articles to this paper, and that recently a vet did come to their clinic and give a presentation on this topic. I did find the name of the vet who is traveling the country giving presentations about this new strain of calici, Dr. Norsworthy, a Texas vet.
Not very surprisingly to me, when I found a link explaining Dr. Norsworthy's work and presentations, the page for "more info" is no longer there:
http://www.goodnewsforpets.com/Articles.asp?ID=699http://www.dvmvac.org/drnorsworthy.htm Doing more digging, I did find this on the same website, and if you just READ the answers this "vet" gives to the questions you can quickly conclude that one of two things are going on here:
1. This vet doesn't know about the most basic aspects of veterinary care and vaccination options, like INTRA-NASAL vaccines.
2. This is SO outdated, it was written in Pre-Intra-Nasal vaccine days, and thus makes it so medically outdated as to be completely useless in modern medicine circles, thus completely removing any credibility to this rumor:
http://www.dvmvac.org/norsworthy_calicivirus.asp Also of note, this entire website (dvmvac.org) is a VERY PRO-VACCINE website, even going so far as to deny the proven facts about VAS and denouncing the new APPROVED feline vaccination guidelines set forth by the Vaccine Associated Sarcoma Task Force and the American Association of Feline Practitioners of every 3 years for many vaccines!
This one particular vet seems to be "in the pocket" of the pro-vaccination people, namely, the vaccine manufacturers. In fact the website dvmvac.org, is run by a company that blatantly, on their main website proudly professes their specialty, making people believe what they need to believe to get the client's message across:
" Germinder
I was afraid I was being paranoid when the first I heard about this disease was in an announcement for the vaccine.
Thanks for all the info. I will say that I found a couple references to it being more widespread.
http://www.animalsheltering.org/resource_library/magazine_articles/may_jun_2004/virulent_systemic_feline_calicivirus.htmlSaying "The study’s investigators described six outbreaks of FCV disease in Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Tennessee, and Nevada, noting several similarities to the west Los Angeles cases."
And another page (darn, I can't find the link now) said it had been reported in the UK as well.
So, I'm not sure what to make of this announcement and hope to discuss it with a vet or two.
Posted
September 06, 2007, 11:56AM
by
drkyla
I am a vet in Canada. A local shelter lost about 200 cats last year to a calici virus outbreak. May cats are being vaccinated against this disease today. The vax just became available in Canada.
I have also heard of many more outbreaks of VS Calici. This is not a reportable disease (meaning you don't have to tell anyone when there is a case) and many shelters, like the one here, don't want publicity when they have a deadly outbreak.
I've been a vet for 20 years, if I had seen a VS Calici, I would not have know what it was, because it is a new mutation to a severely virulent strain.
As for your conspiracy theories, Dr Norsworthy is one of the most respected veterinarians in practice. He literally wrote the textbook on Feline Medicine. He is a man of extreme integrity and regularly challenges conventional wisdom publicly when it doesn't make sense. Anything he does is for the benefit of the patient. He is not for sale.
If you polled veterinarians, you'd very likely find that Dr Jean Dodds is considered highly controversial and not an adherent to the scientific method.
Personally, I would be far more suspect of her than of Dr Norsworthy.
I know people like to think vets are out to rip you off. If we were, wouldn't it make sense to let more animals get gravely ill? There's far more money in intensive care than in administering vaccines and keeping cats healthy.
Posted
April 26, 2007, 1:26PM
by
michelle
This is wonderful news for the kitties. Thanks Jennifer.